| Jennifer Connelly |
Sarah |
| Lonny Price |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Louise Gold |
Self |
| Brian Henson |
Self |
| Johnny Carson |
Self |
| Kevin Clash |
Self |
| Peter Falk |
Tramp |
| Jimmy Dean |
Self |
| Frank Oz |
Fozzie |
| Kathryn Mullen |
Self |
| Jim Henson |
Kermit |
| Christine Nelson |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Steve Whitmire |
Self |
| David Rudman |
Self |
| Jon Stone |
Self |
| Paul Simon |
Self |
| Fran Brill |
Self |
| Jerry Juhl |
Self |
| Mike Wallace |
Self |
| Michael Hirsch |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Jane Henson |
Self |
| Danny DeVito |
Self |
| Ray Charles |
Self |
| Lew Grade |
Self |
| Louis Zorich |
Self |
| Pam Arciero |
Muppet |
| Willie Nelson |
Self |
| Austin Pendleton |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Martin P. Robinson |
Self |
| Jerry Nelson |
Self |
| Francis Ford Coppola |
Self |
| Ted Koppel |
Self |
| Robin Williams |
Self |
| Steve Martin |
Self |
| Candice Bergen |
Self |
| Richard Hunt |
Self |
| Goldie Hawn |
Self |
| Rudolf Nureyev |
Self |
| Harry Belafonte |
Self |
| Rhea Perlman |
Self |
| Maurice Sendak |
Self |
| Eren Ozker |
Self |
| Charles Durning |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Scott Walker |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Juliana Donald |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| David Bowie |
Jareth |
| Stephen Garlick |
Jen |
| Frances Bergen |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| John Landis |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Charles Grodin |
Nicky |
| John Hurt |
Storyteller |
| Roger Moore |
Self |
| Alice Tweedy |
Self |
| Diana Rigg |
Verden Fell (archive footage) |
| Caroll Spinney |
Self |
| Karen Prell |
Self |
| Brian Muehl |
Self |
| Madeline Kahn |
Self |
| Dave Goelz |
Self |